You know it's okay not to get into a game that is popular with most people. Certainly no different to other forms of art / entertainment.
HL and HL2 are puzzle games wrapped in narrative and fps. As such, I reckon they are done very well. I believe people responded to Portal because it hit the same buttons. Have you played that?
◊ Steam shock_ ◊ GFWL shock64738 ◊ BFBC2 shock... ◊ GameSpy TOG|shock