![]() |
Minecraft is now officially part of Australian education
It seems that the national school grading tests (NAPLAN) in Australia today included a touch of Minecraft (Twitter)
Quote:
Sorontar |
haha how cool
feel better soon miniObsi :) |
now was MiniObsi sick, or off for philisophical reasons?
love this |
Hm.. but which one IS punctuated correctly? I think it's the second from the top? or possibly the third from the top...
|
first there should be a pause after "my favourate game" I believe. Second one has no punctuation at al so it reads
my favouate game said liam is minecraft (all run together no pauses or breaks) The fourth one is also a possibility but I think the second ones right, |
The way I see it is that you can remove " said Liam " from the text and end up with only "My favourite game is Minecraft.". Obviously you don't want any punctuation in that sentence so alternative 1 and 4 would be wrong. But I'm not entirely sure if it's number 2 or 3 that is the right one (starting to lean towards 3). Personally I would have added "said Liam" to the end and be done with it ;)
|
Trust the linguist. The fourth option is correct. You need the commas before and after the said Liam. It is treated the same as a complex adverbial phrase in the middle of a sentence,
e.g. The captain of the ship, after reviewing the charts, exited the room. If you start a phrase or clause with punctuation, it must end with them. Sorontar |
Thankfully I'm neither in school any more nor Australian, so that will be my excuse :D
Though, I have to ask, why is the first comma before the " and not after? Shouldn't it be outside the main sentence together with said Liam? |
Quote:
Sorontar |
Nah, American English has it before the quotes as well. Commas and periods always get placed within the quotes and the ends of the appropriate words.
|
| All times are GMT +11. The time now is 02:22 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin®
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.3.0