k I am going to go out on a limb here.........
I luv it
Is it exactly what I wanted in a game/what I am used to? no
Would it be possible to create a game that is exactly what everyone wants? no
Would it be smart to just re skin a game so it is what everyone is used to? no
Coming from an older style computer, i have not had the opportunity to upgrade to games that came out after ET, so I guess my expectations are a little less than everyone else.
You won't have to look hard over the net to find criticisms of the game, so here are the things I like FWIW
- Map Size/Team Size: Whilst to early to tell how it will go comp wise, smaller team sizes and maps will put more emphasis on strategy and team work (which I believe has happened in ET from 7v7 to 5v5)
- Veil/upgrades: similar to xp in a way, but I look at it more as training. With all the money in the world you still have to choose which option you run with (you have a choice of the three weapon upgrades and can't put them all on at the one time). It won't take people long to fully upgrade and i believe it adds another level to the strategy. I hope ladders maintain this option.
- Veil-speed/healing: What a great concept. Only 3 classes with a specific ability. Engy having the ability to run faster and/or build faster (not sure if you can only select one. Have earnt enough money yet). Adds the strat to have engy as doc carrier with med support (again teamwork)
- Delay in objectives/having to look at objective-Not just grab and go, you need to stay there a couple of seconds, you better have good teamwork or you won't last long.
- Options other than stopwatch for pub play - I think is a plus.
- Shooting: More accurate than the hitboxes in ET. I find it honest shooting.
- Engine: Hey I'm no techy. I got in, shot where I aimed. Died a bunch and got some kills. Seemed fairly smooth to me. (although can't wait for a class script to come out).
I jumped on last night for a bit. All being said and done, who were getting the most kills, guys like max and shaggy. Why? cause they are the best shooters around. (although I did find it easier to take down shaggy in Wolf over ET. I think my k/d against him would have been 3/15 or something.
In summary, I think for ladder play, more emphasis on strats and shooting seems honest. Pub play, couple of different types will add variety and smaller team numbers means you don't get the spawn/die/span/die night, that is GA7