The Witcher

Reviewed by Arep | 6 May 2008
Genre: Action | Publisher: Atari | Developer: Projekt Red
TOG Score
Members (av.)
The Good

*Strong graphical presentation. Interesting settings, characters, situations, and story. *Enjoyable and beautifully animated sword combat and engagingly unique combat system. *Good gameplay variety via mini-games. *Fully realized world of Temeria adds a strong backdrop for the action.

The Bad

*Persistent and routine crashes during load screens. *Too many load screens that last too long. *Occasional bit of poor voice-acting. *Spell-casting seems somewhat tacked on.

* Originally authored by Wytefang *

Many PC gamers are eagerly awaiting the release of Funcom’s wild and wooly Age of Conan MMO without realizing that CD Projekt Red, a small development house in Poland, has recently released an extremely enjoyable single-player RPG called “The Witcher” which already captures everything flavorful and cool about the Conan-styled settings and mature themes. Even more surprising is how refreshing and different The Witcher feels compared to pre-existing established RPG franchises. The reasons are varied but well worth exploring.

The primary and most obvious aspect setting The Witcher apart from its peers is the mature and admittedly sexist content. Gamers can only play as the titular male protagonist, Geralt of Rivia, a two-fisted, aloof, sword-wielder monster hunter whose passion for monster slaying seems only matched by his ability to score with the ladies. And those “extra-curricular” opportunities abound throughout the game. If you’re careful and clever enough with your witty dialog choices, you’ll share many an enjoyable evening with a wide variety of attractive and interesting female characters. You’re actually rewarded for this behavior with a card-sized picture of your, er, “conquest” in partially nude form, to show around to all your Witcher buddies. While this may be unpalatable to some, it lends the Witcher’s world of Temeria a lusty medieval fantasy ambiance that catches one’s interest a bit more than the usual fare and even becomes a sort of mini-game unto itself, if you’re so inclined.

While the plot teeters on a trite precipice from time to time, the journey there is very much worthwhileAside from the horizontal shenanigans, there are plenty of tricky moral dilemmas to tightrope across throughout the course of the remarkably involving storyline which involves a calculated plot to discredit and destroy the few remaining Witchers in the world. While the plot teeters on a trite precipice from time to time, the journey there is very much worthwhile, and things pick up towards the latter of the game’s segments. Dialogue is delivered by voice-acting that’s better than expected overall but which occasionally suffers from the random wonky performance. Adding to the game’s mature feel is the haphazard usage of fairly modern swear words. It’s one thing to hear an NPC cry out for your head on a stake but it’s an entirely different situation when some surly street-fighter tells you that one of your close familial members sucks (expletive edited out to keep this a family-friendly review site). If the cuss words were sprinkled evenly throughout this game and were more consistent with the flavor of the time-period, this wouldn’t be as off-putting.

Another small, but bizarrely anachronistic aspect of The Witcher’s story is the frequently mentioned and apparently well-understood aspect of Genetics. Last I checked, medieval peasant types lacked the basic understanding of even the most rudimentary forms of science, let along the nuances of a highly complicated scientific field. Not only is the term “Genetics” mentioned verbatim but the characters referring to this challenging science seemed remarkably well-versed in it. It’s not a major gripe, by any means, but something odd that ruins a bit of the game’s ambiance.

the developers (CD Projekt) actually enlisted the motion-captured aid of several bona fide medieval sword mastersYou’d be forgiven, however, if you initially find the game’s combat system also somewhat off-putting. Unlike traditional action-based mouse click-fests, The Witcher provides a novel and patience-requiring approach to combat that involves the use of proper timing in order to chain a series of attacks together. To further enhance combat variety and boost the element of strategic thought while slugging things out, players need to be able to understand (and have researched) the monsters they’re facing in Temeria. Foreknowledge helps you know which type of sword and potion will best suit Geralt in even his easiest battles. Geralt fights with either a special Witcher’s steel sword (mostly for human or humanoid creatures) or a more monster-unfriendly silver sword. Each offers three styles, Fast – for quick-hitting, lightly-armored foes, Strong – for those buff, muscle-bound sluggers, and Group – for facing, you guessed it, multiple foes. Unfortunately, you never really seem to have any use for the other weapons you may stumble across during the game – the Witcher’s swords are far too potent. One cool aspect of combat that doesn’t seem to be getting a lot of review coverage is that the developers (CD Projekt) actually enlisted the motion-captured aid of several bona fide medieval sword masters, so Geralt’s wickedly cool combat animations look even better than they normally would. It’s something best seen live during gameplay to be fully appreciated but it ramps up the visceral enjoyment that much more.

Though it’s a small thing and something expected of these type of genre games, the leveling up process, where you’re granted points to better develop your growing abilities is both thought-provoking and difficult to abuse. Every player’s version of Geralt by game’s end will look and play differently because The Witcher doesn’t strive to provide a fully-realized talent path as much as it does a “Jack-of-all-Trades” talent progression. Some may find this frustrating but it leads to characters better able to handle everything the game may throw at them, so in that regard, it’s definitely a good thing.

I also mentioned “potions” because one of the important tools every good Witcher learns to employ during his career involves the careful brewing of powerful magical concoctions that provide useful buffs or enhancements during combat. Everything from night-vision, to Matrix-style slow-motion perception and reflexes can be whipped up with enough of the right natural ingredients. This adds an amusing diversion to all the monster-mashing you’ll do while solving the game’s primary plot. This isn’t the only fun little mini-game, though – along the way you’ll be able to engage in gambling, drinking, and street-boxing events that offer experience, money, or sometimes both. These bring a variety to the proceedings that is sorely missed in other more determinedly single-minded RPGs. For those who hanker for a bit of spell-slinging, Geralt also utilizes a variety of different “signs” (read: Spells) to aid him during combat. However, these are all rather basic and in some cases they feel tacked on as much as useful.

ambience-supporting musical themes grace many important areas while never reaching a level of annoyanceGraphics seem to scale well, even on lower settings, while the highest settings are impressive enough to make combat just that much more enjoyable. Sound is another strong aspect, as ambience-supporting musical themes grace many important areas while never reaching a level of annoyance. One unfortunate issue is that under Vista (at least) the game regularly crashes during loading screens. Thankfully a PC-friendly save-anywhere type system keeps this frustration mostly at bay but it doesn’t address the other main complaint – the annoyingly frequent need for loading screens. These loading screens seem less bothersome if you’re running at least 2 gigs of RAM but those without that amount should be prepared to be patient.

One final issue to consider is that CD Projekt has recently announced the future release of an “Enhanced Edition” of The Witcher, with improved graphics, better stability, and many other gameplay-improving changes. In light of this newly announced version, gamers interested in trying out this rollicking good RPG may want to wait before plunking down their hard-earned cash on the non-enhanced version. It’s also worth noting that the North American version of The Witcher has edited out any nudity while the European versions have toned down the gore a bit – though the Euro version seems to have much better scripting and translation than its North American counterpart. Regardless of which version you eventually decide to purchase, one thing is clear: this is hands-down one of the most enjoyable, refreshing, and depth-filled role-playing games in years. Fans of the genre or even those just looking for an engaging story or setting will find plenty here to amuse them.

ESRB: M (Mature) for sexually suggestive elements, nudity, violence, and language, as well as Adult themes

Plays like: Planescape Torment mixed with the adult themes of Grand Theft Auto, and a healthy dose of Diablo-style combat action tempered via the use of an golf-swing meter-styled attack method.

What do you think of The Witcher?
Post a review below!

Popular The Witcher Videos

Videos courtesy of

Member reviews

that is amazing - adhamgamal |
| 19 March 2015

just amazed by this العاب بن تن

csnk - csnk |
| 29 May 2015

just amazed by thisclothing manufacturer

- peterstrong |
| 11 July 2016

good, the content is simple, easy to understand

Write a review

 You must be logged in to post a review.

Poll: How much time do you game each week?

Popular articles

Popular videos

Courtesy of | Top 20 »